Did History Actually Teach Us Anything? - Episode 16 The Black Death (The Plague)

Laura: Welcome to "Did History Actually Teach Us Anything?" 
The podcast where we unravel the most well-known tales of calamity, mishap, and unforeseen consequences that have shaped the course of history. And consider whether we've actually learned anything from them all these years later.. 
In this podcast, we examine the historical events that you may think you know about already and the causes that led to them, be they icebergs or bakers ovens. 
We will consider whether these tragedies could have been avoided, and some of the surprising things we do differently now as a result. 
But this podcast isn't just about dates and events. It's about learning from the past, drawing insights from hindsight, and gaining a deeper appreciation for the complexities of what really happened in these events we think we know so well. 
So get ready to encounter remarkable individuals, pivotal moments and fascinating insights that will make you appreciate health and safety and environmental management as far more than just red tape. 
In the middle of the 14th century, life across Europe was about to change forever. What began as whispers of a strange illness arriving on merchant ships quickly grew into one of the most devastating pandemics in human history, the Black Death. By 1347, this disease was spreading with terrifying speed, leaving behind a trail of fear, chaos, and unimaginable loss. Communities that had thrived for centuries were suddenly torn apart. Families were destroyed overnight, and entire towns were left abandoned.
In this episode, we explore how a disease was able to spread with such devastating speed across continents, leaving communities powerless in its wake. The Black Death was more than a medical catastrophe - it was a disease that exposed the fragility of medieval society, reshaped economies, and altered the course of history.
Joining us to unpick the story is one of our health and safety experts, Lucy, who is going to help us understand not just how the Black Death spread, but also how societies responded to a crisis unlike anything they had ever seen before. 

Lucy: The Black Death - also known simply as the plague - was one of the deadliest pandemics in human history. It first reached Europe in 1347 and, within just a few years, swept across the continent with absolutely devastating speed. We are talking about between 25 and 30 million deaths - roughly a third of Europe's entire population at the time. To put that into perspective Laura, that's like losing everyone in London, Birmingham, Manchester and Leeds combined - several times over. Unlike an accident in a single location, this was a continent-wide disaster that touched every city, town, and village it passed through.
The consequences were catastrophic on every level. Entire communities were depopulated. Trade routes that had sustained economies for generations simply collapsed. Labor shortages led to profound social and economic upheaval that lasted for decades. Authorities - from local councils to the church - struggled desperately to cope with the crisis, and their inability to protect people from the disease severely undermined public trust. In many places, the aftermath brought long-term decline in prosperity, widespread social unrest, and lasting changes to the way societies were structured.
What strikes me most about this pandemic is how quickly it overwhelmed everything. Medieval Europe had survived wars, famines, and localised outbreaks of disease before, but nothing had prepared them for something of this scale and speed.

Laura: So what were the health and safety causes of the pandemic? Was there anything that could have been done differently at the time? 

Lucy: That's the difficult thing about the Black Death, Laura. Looking at it through the lens of modern health and safety, we can see that no single individual or group can be held responsible - this was a pandemic driven by circumstances far beyond the understanding of people at the time. There were crucial factors that allowed it to spread so rapidly, however, and some of them would be glaringly obvious to us today.
Firstly, the movement of ships, traders, and armies acted as carriers of the disease, but little effort was made to restrict or monitor travel. The authorities simply did not recognize that contact between people, animals, and goods could transmit diseases, so there were no effective barriers to stop its advance. Ships would dock in ports, unload cargo and passengers, and sail onto the next destination - unknowingly spreading infection with every stop.
Secondly, crucial details about hygiene and sanitation were completely overlooked. Living conditions in overcrowded medieval towns were frankly horrific by modern standards. Poor waste disposal, open sewers, contaminated water supplies, and the close presence of rats and fleas created the perfect environment for infection to thrive. People simply did not have the knowledge to identify these hazards, meaning the obvious health and safety steps - such as isolating the sick, cleaning, water supplies, or controlling pests - were either delayed or ignored entirely.
Finally, the response systems that did exist, such as local councils and the Church, were overwhelmed and often ineffective. In some areas, attempts were made to close city gates or establish rudimentary quarantines, but these measures were inconsistent, poorly enforced, and usually came far too late. By the time authorities realized the severity of the threat, the disease had already taken hold.
So while we can't blame medieval people for not having knowledge they couldn't possibly possess, the combination of poor living conditions, limited medical understanding, and a complete lack of coordinated preventative measures meant that Europe was utterly unprepared for an event of this scale.

Laura: What would it have been like for ordinary people living through the Black Death? How quickly did communities realize what they were facing?

Lucy: Imagine if you will, life in a typical medieval town. One day everything is normal - the market is bustling, people are going about their daily business. Then, someone mentions that a few people have fallen ill with strange symptoms. Maybe there's talk of unusual deaths in the next town over. At first, people might not think much of it - illness was a common part of medieval life.
But then it accelerates. Within days, dozens of people are sick. Within weeks, bodies are piling up faster than they can be buried. The symptoms were absolutely horrific - painful swellings in the groin, armpits and neck called buboes, which gave the disease its name, the "bubonic plague". Victims would develop dark patches on their skin where blood vessels had burst, hence "the Black Death". Most people died within three to five days of showing symptoms.
What made it particularly terrifying was how indiscriminate it was. It didn't matter if you were rich or poor, young or old, devout or sinful. The disease struck everyone. Families watched their loved ones die in agony, knowing they might be next. Physicians, who were supposed to help, often refuse to treat the sick or fled the cities entirely. Priests, who should have offered comfort, sometimes abandoned their parishes rather than risk infection.
The social fabric completely broke down in many places. Fields went unharvested because there was no one left to work them. Shops closed. Trade stopped. In some villages everyone died, leaving ghost towns scattered across the landscape. Those who survived often found themselves alone, having lost their entire family.
And remember, these people had no understanding of germ theory, no concept of bacteria or how disease spread. Many believed it was divine punishment for sin, or caused by "bad air" or unfavourable planetary alignments. Some thought the disease spread through simply looking at infected people. This lack of understanding meant that people took actions that actually made things worse - like gathering in churches to pray for deliverance, which just spread the infection faster.

Laura: That's absolutely harrowing. Are there any measures that could have been taken to stop the disease from taking hold?

Lucy: It's difficult to say The Black Death could ever have been completely avoided, given the limited medical knowledge of the 14th century. People did not understand how disease was transmitted, and the connection between rats, fleas, and infection was centuries away from being discovered. However, Laura, if certain health and safety principles had been applied, even in their most basic form, the scale of the disaster might have been significantly reduced. 
Let me break down what we know about why it spread so devastatingly. The plague bacterium, Yersinia pestis, was carried by fleas that lived on black rats. These rats thrived in the unsanitary conditions of medieval towns and travelled on ships, spreading the disease along trade routes. When an infected flea bit a human, the bacteria entered the bloodstream, causing the bubonic form of the plague. In some cases, it developed into pneumonic plague, which could spread directly from person to person through respiratory droplets - making it even more deadly.
Now, even without understanding the specific mechanisms, certain measures could have made a difference. Stricter controls on trade and travel could have slowed the spread considerably. Quarantining ships arriving from affected ports, limiting the movement of people between towns, and inspecting goods might have prevented the disease from traveling so quickly across Europe. Some Italian city-states actually did implement rudimentary versions of these measures, and it's notable that they tended to fare somewhat better than places that didn't.
Improved sanitation and waste disposal could have made a real difference. Crowded and filthy living conditions created the perfect environment for rats and fleas to thrive. Better waste management, clearer water supplies and efforts to control the rat population might have reduced transmission rates. Early recognition of infection and the isolation of the sick, if applied consistently, might have allowed some communities to protect themselves more effectively.
In the modern day, these measures form the absolute foundation of public health practice. International monitoring systems track the spread of disease in real time. Borders can be closed or controlled. Strict quarantine measures are enforced to contain outbreaks. Hygiene standards, pest control, clean water supplies, and the ability to rapidly share scientific knowledge all help limit the impact of new illnesses. Vaccines, antibiotics, and emergency health planning add further layers of protection. We saw many of these principles in action during the COVID-19 pandemic of 2019-2023. International travel restrictions, contact tracing systems, public health, messaging about hygiene and social distancing, the rapid development and rollout of vaccines - these are all direct descendants of lessons learned from historical pandemics like the Black Death. Even the term "lockdown" is essentially a modern version of the medieval practice of closing city gates. The difference is that we now have the scientific understanding and technology to implement these measures far more effectively. Had even a fraction of these measures been available in the 14th century, the Black Death would almost certainly not have reached the catastrophic scale It did.
So, while the people of Medieval Europe cannot be blamed for lacking the tools and understanding we have today, the Black Death stands as a stark reminder of how vital health and safety principles are. It shows us that without systems to detect, contain, and respond to hazards, even the strongest societies can be left vulnerable to complete collapse.

Laura: Were there any attempts at all to control the spread during the outbreak? 

Lucy: There were some attempts, yes, and they're actually quite interesting from a health and safety perspective because they represent some of the earliest organized public health responses in European history. 
Some city authorities did try to implement travel bans, closing their gates to travelers arriving from infected areas. Venice, for example, established a forty-day isolation period for arriving vessels - this gave us the word "quarantine", which comes from the Italian "quaranta giorni", meaning forty days. Ships had to anchor offshore and wait before their cruise and cargo could disembark. This was actually remarkably forward-thinking for the time, even if they didn't fully understand why it worked.
Other cities tried to control the movement of goods and people within their walls. Some banned public gatherings, closed markets, and even prohibited funerals, which was hugely controversial in a deeply religious society where proper burial rights were considered essential for salvation.
There are also attempts to improve sanitation. Some towns ordered streets to be cleaned and waste to be removed more regularly. Others tried to eliminate "bad air" by lighting fires or burning aromatic substances, which obviously didn't help with the disease, but did at least show an attempt to address environmental factors.
The problem was these measures were inconsistent, poorly coordinated, and often came too late. There was no central authority to implement continent-wide responses. Each town, each region and each kingdom acted independently, often only taking action after the disease had already arrived. Because people didn't understand the true cause of the plague, even well-intentioned efforts were often misdirected. 
What's particularly tragic is that in some places, fear and desperation led to horrific scapegoating. Jewish communities were accused of poisoning wells and faced terrible persecution, including massacres. This represents the absolute worst of human behavior during a crisis - turning fear into hatred and violence against vulnerable groups.

Laura: What immediate changes came about as a result of the Black Death, and did it lead to any early public health measures? 

Lucy: The Black Death left such devastation in its wake that it forced fundamental changes in how health and safety - although the term didn't exist at the time - was understood and applied. The experience of the plague led to some of the earliest developments in public health measures that we would recognize today.
Parliament passed laws to regulate waste disposal and prevent the pollution of water sources. City authorities established more formal systems for monitoring and controlling disease spread - the quarantine measures I mentioned earlier became more standardized across European ports. These measures mark the first steps toward formal systems of disease prevention and control.
From a purely practical standpoint, the Black Death led to improvements in medical practice as well. Physicians began to keep more detailed records of symptoms and disease progression. The concept of contagion - that disease could spread from person to person - began to be more widely accepted, even if the mechanisms weren't understood. Universities started to place more emphasis on practical medical training rather than just theoretical knowledge. 
So while the Black Death didn't lead to prosecutions, fines, or direct legal forms in the way a modern disaster might, it did fundamentally transform the way societies thought about collective safety. For the first time, organised responses to public health threats were seen as necessary responsibilities of governments and local councils.

Laura: Beyond the health measures, what were the wider social impacts? Did the plague change society in any other ways? 

Lucy: The wider implications were enormous, Laura. The labor shortages caused by such massive death tolls gave surviving workers new bargaining power. Suddenly, there weren't enough laborers to work the fields or craftspeople to produce goods. This led to demands for higher wages and better working conditions - which, interestingly, prompted governments to try to suppress these demands. The English "Statute of Labourers" in 1351 attempted to freeze pay and control movement of workers, but these laws were met with resentment and unrest, eventually fueling up rises, such as the Peasants' Revolt of 1381.
The authority of the church was also profoundly shaken. Its inability to protect people from the plague or even to provide satisfactory explanations for why God would allow such suffering cause many to question religious institutions. This contributed to a gradual shift in how people thought about the world and their place in it. The social consequences, economic upheaval, unrest, and shifting attitudes towards authority were just as significant as the immediate human toll.
What strikes me most, though, is how this disaster from nearly 700 years ago still forms our approach to pandemics today. The basic principles - early detection, isolation of the sick, quarantine of contacts, control of movement, improve sanitation - these are the exact same tools we use in a modern outbreak response. We've just got better technology and a better understanding of the science behind them.
The Black Death was a tragedy on an almost incomprehensible scale, but it taught humanity crucial lessons about the importance of public health infrastructure, coordinated response to disease threats, and the need to provide collective safety over individual convenience or commercial interests. Those lessons remain absolutely vital today.

Laura: Thanks for joining us on this episode of "Did History Actually Teach Us Anything?". 
If you enjoyed this episode, please follow our social media channels, leave us a rating and review, and share our podcast with anyone who wants to learn more about the risky side of history. 
And don't forget to subscribe so you'll get the next episode as soon as it's available. Join us next time to learn whether history did actually teach us anything.